Back in 2024, I asked the question whether £1 million was enough. Enough for what, exactly? A comfortable retirement? To replace a big lottery win?

Pat on the back if you remember that the question related to new(ish) powers of The Pensions Regulator (TPR) to issue a financial penalty of up to £1 million, and whether that was sufficient to act as a deterrent for those tempted to take actions that might adversely impact their pension scheme.
Actions that are capable of attracting this higher £1 million financial penalty include:
- providing false or misleading information to TPR or pension scheme trustees
- failure to comply with a contribution notice
- failure to comply with the notifiable events regime, and
- committing the offences of “avoidance of employer debt” or “conduct risking accrued scheme benefits”.
When the government first announced in 2018 that it would strengthen TPR’s powers, the Work and Pensions Committee, which had run inquiries into the collapse of both BHS and Carillion and the subsequent pension scheme deficits, were particularly scathing of the potential £1 million penalty.
So far as Frank Field was concerned, £1 million just wasn’t enough. He said, “The accountancy profession must have been in charge of drafting this section of the paper, as it appears they have misplaced a decimal point. The likes of Sir Philip Green need to be fined a billion, not a million, if the Regulator is to have a deterrent effect.”







